Old Town Pizza Co

Jeremiah Newman 3 months ago

Their meatball sandwich is fire, I've had a lot of the different sandwiches here and have never been disappointed. However I strongly recommend the meatballs here however you want them, they're packed with so much flavor!

Jennifer E 3 months ago

I ordered delivery and was honestly really happy with everything. The pizza showed up hot, fresh, and still had that great crispy-but-chewy crust like it just came out of the oven. Toppings were generous and tasted high quality, not skimpy or soggy like some places. Even for delivery, everything was packaged well and held up great on the ride over. The service was smooth too—easy ordering, accurate timing, and no issues with the order at all. Overall, it’s one of those spots you can count on when you don’t feel like going out but still want really good pizza. Definitely ordering again.

stephanie justice 3 months ago

Did a pick up order of Pizza and Mozzarella Sticks. Order was easy to place over the phone and was ready pretty quick. We had the Mozzarella Sticks, which were decent and paired well with the Marinera Sauce, which had very good flavor. We also got the specialty thin crust pizza with Pepperoni, Bacon, and Banana Peppers. We liked the crust because it still had some crisp to it. We will order from here again.

Desmond Pentony 6 months ago

​I usually only leave good reviews, but there is a first time for everything. To be honest, the pizza here was genuinely well done. However, the customer service experience was a deep letdown. I called recently (Feb. 25th, 7:18pm) regarding a missing topping and was told I would receive a "pizza credit." I even double-checked with the staff by asking, "Do you mean a credit for a pizza?" and they confirmed that was correct. ​That day was my first time ever ordering from here. Just a small mistake, which was fine; the pizza was still delicious and I was impressed. However when I called to redeem the credit today (Mar. 9th, 6:28pm), I was told it was only a "topping credit." That would have been perfectly fine if that is what was said originally, but when confirming a specific solution and agreeing to it, you should honor it. If you mean a "topping credit" don't say "pizza credit." Having two negative experiences in a row as a first-time customer is not a pleasant experience and it is unfortunate to lose a local customer over a small misunderstanding like this, but the lack of consistency makes it hard to return.

Fly Doll Ronda 9 months ago

I DoorDash a few days a week occasionally for a little extra cash around the holidays, and ai stumbled upon this place after picking up a DoorDash order for a customer! I was planning on getting Little Cesar’s to feed a family of 5, but as soon as I walked in and saw how good those slices looked, and the yummy smells, I knew instantly I wanted food from here haha. I called back and ordered on my way to drop off the customers order! The staff is sooo friendly, especially the lovely woman at the front desk, and I love supporting family owned businesses!! It goes without saying the food is absolutely incredible 11/10!! No exaggeration the pizza, wings, and jalapeño poppers were soooo good. This will be my families go to spot from now on :)